‘What is Given? What is Taken’ by Alexander Koleszar

Painting displays the complex nature of providing care to a parent living with dementia
A painting. One hand reaches through a prison door, holding a metronome. Another pair of hands, older, reaches through a prison door, attempting to grab the object. The background shows a theme of discourse, with a large crack in the ground.
Submitted by:

What is What is Given? What is Taken?, and how did it come to be? 

I am an artist. My work is often closely related to my personal experiences in life. In addition to working as an artist, I’ve been a caregiver for 11 years now. 

I moved from California to Arizona to help my parents at the beginning of 2016. At that time, my father, John, was in his early 90s with signs of dementia. My mother, Ann, had not yet developed any outward signs. But over the past 11 years, I’ve taken on greater responsibilities. 

My father passed in 2020. At that point, my mother began to show clear signs of dementia. In her case, there was a lot of anger and lashing out at those around her. In spite of that, I, along with my siblings, have done everything in our power to keep her in her own home—something she had requested decades ago.

What is Given? What is Taken? is a painting that depicts my mother’s hands on the right and my right hand on the left. The painting is accompanied by 2 pages of text that act as another window into the day-to-day struggle of the needs of a caregiver and their loved one. 

Our relationship is not about time. It is about those slow ticking elements that seem to go back and forth that make sense to her, but not to me, much like a metronome. Every day, for sixteen hours, I give her my time, my ability to remain patient, my attention, my responses, no matter how many times I am asked the same question. I am giving her what dementia demands. Financial support and oversight. Proper care. Doctor’s appointments. Daily medicine. Meals. And desserts—she has become like a child wanting desserts—preferably ice cream. She occasionally responds in a way that reaffirms there is some aspect of my mother that is still present. And for this reason, I will stay with her until she dies. 

Who initially inspired you to grapple with dementia? 

I’ve always been close to my parents, especially my mom. When my father passed, my mom was showing clear signs of dementia. I was told I should consider placing her in a facility. I could not do that. I had always promised her I would do everything in my power to make sure she is never placed in a home—unless I am no longer physically capable of handling her care. So for me, it was about a commitment to her. That is why I grapple with her dementia.

How has working on dementia-related art changed you?

Dementia has had a dramatic impact on my artwork. I have written a book (The Architecture of Grace—Painting Dementia. A Son’s Reflections on Care, Memory and Meaning). It has not been published, as my work as a caregiver continues. But most of my paintings over the last 10 years are about dementia and its impact on me as an artist. There are so many levels of dementia, and so much to sort through. All caregivers understand this. The task is easily one of the most difficult out there.

How has What is Given? What is Taken? been received? 

I have shown the painting to my mother. She doesn’t fully understand it, but she loves the painting. She recognizes her hands—or more accurately, she recognizes the rings on her hand. Others who have seen it and read the accompanying text are deeply moved by what the painting says.

This work is dedicated to: This painting is dedicated to all caregivers. My heart is with you. You know what is given, and what is taken.

Find more from Alex Koleszar on the website. And his previous Spotlight for his work with Painting Dementia: A Son’s Reflections on Care, Memory and Meaning.

What is a Spotlight?

The Dementia Arts Spotlight promotes visual and performing artists who are grappling with dementia through original work or innovative arts programs. The Spotlight—in a Q&A format where artists describe the details and significance of their work or program—connects each artist to the Dementia Spring community. Find examples of prior Dementia Arts Spotlights here. Know of an artist whose work should be Spotlighted? Send them this link!

Did you enjoy this content?

A social share is a simple gift ❤️ that helps us increase awareness and expand our reach. All content is produced by a group of dedicated professionals🧑‍💻 living all across the globe. 🌎 

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Pinterest

Dementia Spring is a non-profit organization funded by donations from our generous followers. Learn how you can support us.

We also give back with grants for artists and art organizations! 💰

You may also enjoy these artists: